Configuring Oracle ACFS Snapshot-Based Replication

18 Configuring Oracle ACFS Snapshot-Based Replication

The requirements for Oracle ACFS snapshot-based replication are discussed in this section.

This chapter describes how to configure Oracle ACFS snapshot-based replication available with release 12.2 or higher. As with Oracle ACFS replication installations before release 12.2, the overall functional goal of snapshot-based replication is to ensure that updates from a primary cluster are replicated to a standby cluster. However, the snapshot based replication technology uses snapshots of the primary storage location and transfers the differences between successive snapshots to the standby storage location using the standard ssh command. Oracle ACFS replication functionality before release 12.2 replicated changes continuously, building on Oracle networking technologies, notably Network Foundation Technologies (NFT), to ensure connectivity between the primary and standby clusters.

This change in the design and implementation of Oracle ACFS replication introduces some differences in how replication is configured and used. For example, the use of ssh requires setting up host and user keys appropriately on the primary and standby nodes where replication is performed.

Oracle ACFS replication also provides a role reversal capability that you can configure by enabling both the primary cluster and the standby cluster to communicate with the other as required. In role reversal, the standby assumes the role of the primary and the primary becomes the standby.

This chapter contains the following topics:

For an overview of Oracle ACFS replication, refer to Oracle ACFS Replication. For information about Oracle ACFS replication commands, refer to Oracle ACFS Command-Line Tools for Replication.

Configuring ssh for Use With Oracle ACFS Replication

This topic describes how to configure ssh for use by Oracle ACFS snapshot-based replication available with release 12.2 or higher.

Oracle ACFS snapshot-based replication uses ssh as the transport between the primary and standby clusters. To support the full capabilities of replication, ssh must be usable in either direction between the clusters — from the primary cluster to the standby cluster and from the standby to the primary.

The procedures in this topic describe how to configure ssh for replication in one direction — from the primary to the standby. To configure ssh completely, you must perform the instructions a second time with the primary and standby roles reversed. When you perform the instructions the first time, complete the steps as written for the primary cluster and the standby cluster. The second time, reverse the primary and standby roles. Perform the steps marked as necessary on the primary cluster on your standby cluster and perform the steps marked as necessary on the standby cluster on your primary cluster. The procedures that must be performed twice are described in:

After you have completed all the necessary procedures, you can use the instructions described in Validating your ssh-related key configuration to confirm that you have configured ssh correctly in both directions.

Choosing an Oracle ACFS replication user

Oracle ACFS snapshot-based replication uses ssh as the transport between the primary and standby clusters, so the user identity under which replication is performed on the standby must be carefully managed. In the replication process, the root user (or local SYSTEM on Windows) on the primary node where replication is running uses ssh to log in to the standby node involved in replication.

Because it is not advisable for ssh to log in as root on the standby node, a minimally-privileged user identity should be used. The user chosen should have Oracle ASM administration privileges. Usually, the user specified to the Oracle installer when the Oracle software was first installed belongs to the needed groups, so can be convenient to choose as the replication user. In this discussion, the replication user is identified as repluser; however, you would replace repluser with the actual user name that you have selected. For information about user privileges for Oracle ASM, refer to About Privileges for Oracle ASM. For information about running Oracle ACFS acfsutil commands, refer to About Using Oracle ACFS Command-Line Tools.

Note:

The same user must be specified as repluser on both your primary cluster and your standby cluster.

Distributing keys for Oracle ACFS replication

The process of distributing keys for Oracle ACFS replication includes getting a public key from the primary cluster, getting host keys for the standby cluster, ensuring permissions are configured properly for ssh-related files, configuring sshd as necessary, and lastly validating the ssh configuration.

Note:

When creating host keys, ensure that you create keys for both fully-qualified domain hostnames and the local hostnames.

Getting a public key for root from the primary cluster

A public key for root defined on each node of your primary cluster must be known to repluser on each node of your standby cluster.

To make the key known, the directory ~repluser/.ssh must exist on each standby node. If this directory does not exist, then create it with access only for repluser. Ensure that an ls command for the .ssh directory displays output similar to:

repluser@standby $ ls -ld ~/.ssh
drwx------ 2 repluser dba 4096 Jan 27 17:01 .ssh

If a public key for root is defined on a given primary node, then it resides in a .pub file, such as /root/.ssh/id_rsa.pub. If a public key file exists, then add its contents to the set of keys authorized to log in as repluser on each node of the standby where replication is run. Append the key to the file ~repluser/.ssh/authorized_keys2 on each standby node, creating this file if necessary.

If a public key file does not exist, generate a public and private key pair on the primary by running the following command as root.

# ssh-keygen -t rsa

You can press the enter key in response to each prompt issued by the command. Copy the resulting .pub file to each standby node.

You have the option to share the same public/private key pair for root across all of the nodes in your primary cluster, or to establish a different key pair for each primary node. If the same public key is valid for root across all nodes in your primary cluster, then only that key must be added to the file ~repluser/.ssh/authorized_keys2 on each node of your standby cluster. If each primary node has its own public key for root, then all the public keys must be added to the file. In either case, you can minimize work by copying the updated authorized_keys2 file on a given node of the standby to the other nodes of the cluster.

Getting host keys for the standby cluster

A host key for each standby node where replication may run must be known on each primary node where replication may run. One way to generate the correct key is to run ssh manually as root from each primary node to each standby node. If the correct host key is not known already, then a warning displays and you can enable ssh to add the key.

Note that there are two users involved in the ssh connection. While ssh on the primary node connects to the standby node as root, ssh logs in on the standby node as repluser. Any command run by ssh on the standby runs with the privileges of repluser, not with root privileges.

Because the primary node connects to the standby node as user root, the host key for the standby node must be added to the known_hosts file of the root user, not the file for repluser. The following is an example of obtaining a host key:

[root@primary usm]# ssh repluser@standby date
The authenticity of host 'standby (10.137.13.85)' can't be established.
RSA key fingerprint is 1b:a9:c6:68:47:b4:ec:7c:df:3a:f0:2a:6f:cf:a7:0a.
Are you sure you want to continue connecting (yes/no)?

If you respond with yes, then the ssh setup is complete. A host key for host standby is stored in the known_hosts file (~root/.ssh/known_hosts) on the host primary for the user root.

After the host key setup for standby nodes is complete on a given primary node, you need to perform an additional step if you use a Virtual IP address (VIP) to communicate with your standby cluster. You must add the VIP name or address at the start of each line of the known_hosts file that refers to a host in the standby cluster. For example, if you use a VIP with the name standby12_vip, and your known_hosts file contains the following two lines that refer to your standby:

standby1,10.242.20.22 ssh-rsa
AAAAB3NzaC1yc2EAAAADAQABAAABAQC3pM2YTd4UUiEWEoCKDGgaTgsmPkQToDrdtU+JtVIq/96muivU
BaJUK83aqzeNIQkh+hUULsUdgKoKT5bxrWYqhY6AlTEqNgBHjBrJt9C73BbQd9y48jsc2G+WQWyuI/
+s1Q+hIJdBNMxvMBQAfisPWWUcaIx9Y/JzlPgF6lRP2cbfqAzixDot9fqRrAKL3G6A75A/6TbwmEW07d1zqOv
l7ZGyeDYf5zQ72F/V0P9UgMEt/5DmcYTn3kTVGjOTbnRBe4A4lY4rVw5c+nZBDFre66XtORfQgwQB5ztW/Pi
08GYbcIszKoZx2HST9AZxYIAgcrnNYG2Ae0K6QLxxxScP
standby2,10.242.20.23 ssh-rsa
AAAAB3NzaC1yc2EAAAADAQABAAABAQDIszcjzNtKN03SY8Kl846skFTVP1HF/ykswbmkctEjL6KTWTW+NR
U4MGbvkBqqdXxuPCR7aoGO2U3PEOg1UVf3DWUoux8IRvqKU+dJcdTibMFkDAIhTnzb14gZ/lRTjn+GYsuP5
Qz2vgL/U0ki887mZCRjWVL1b5FNH8sXBUV2QcD7bjF98VXF6n4gd5UiIC3jv6l2nVTKDwtNHpUTS1dQAi+1D
tr0AieZTsuxXMaDdUZHgKDotjciMB3mCkKm/u3IFoioDqdZE4+vITX9G7DBN4CVPXawp+b5Kg8X9P+08Eehu
tMlBJ5lafy1bxoVlXUDLVIIFBJNKrsqBvxxxpS7

To enable the use of the VIP, you would modify these two lines to read as follows:

standby12_vip,standby1,10.242.20.22 ssh-rsa
AAAAB3NzaC1yc2EAAAADAQABAAABAQC3pM2YTd4UUiEWEoCKDGgaTgsmPkQToDrdtU+JtVIq/96muivU
BaJUK83aqzeNIQkh+hUULsUdgKoKT5bxrWYqhY6AlTEqNgBHjBrJt9C73BbQd9y48jsc2G+WQWyuI/
+s1Q+hIJdBNMxvMBQAfisPWWUcaIx9Y/JzlPgF6lRP2cbfqAzixDot9fqRrAKL3G6A75A/6TbwmEW07d1zqOv
l7ZGyeDYf5zQ72F/V0P9UgMEt/5DmcYTn3kTVGjOTbnRBe4A4lY4rVw5c+nZBDFre66XtORfQgwQB5ztW/Pi
08GYbcIszKoZx2HST9AZxYIAgcrnNYG2Ae0K6QLxxxScP
standby12_vip,standby2,10.242.20.23 ssh-rsa
AAAAB3NzaC1yc2EAAAADAQABAAABAQDIszcjzNtKN03SY8Kl846skFTVP1HF/ykswbmkctEjL6KTWTW+NR
U4MGbvkBqqdXxuPCR7aoGO2U3PEOg1UVf3DWUoux8IRvqKU+dJcdTibMFkDAIhTnzb14gZ/lRTjn+GYsuP5
Qz2vgL/U0ki887mZCRjWVL1b5FNH8sXBUV2QcD7bjF98VXF6n4gd5UiIC3jv6l2nVTKDwtNHpUTS1dQAi+1D
tr0AieZTsuxXMaDdUZHgKDotjciMB3mCkKm/u3IFoioDqdZE4+vITX9G7DBN4CVPXawp+b5Kg8X9P+08Eehu
tMlBJ5lafy1bxoVlXUDLVIIFBJNKrsqBvxxxpS7

Ultimately, the host key configuration performed on this first node of your primary cluster must be performed on every node in your primary cluster; the result of the above sequence, or an equivalent, must exist on each primary node. One way to minimize the manual effort required to achieve this configuration is to update the known_hosts file on one node of the primary cluster, then copy the updated file to the other nodes of the cluster.

Note:

By default, replication enables strict host key checking by ssh, to ensure that the primary node connects to the intended standby node or cluster when it runs ssh. However, if you are certain that this checking is unneeded, such as the case when the primary and standby clusters communicate over a private network, the use of strict host key checking by ssh can be disabled. For information about disabling strict host key checking, refer to the -o sshStrictKey=no option of the acfsutil repl init primary command. If strict host key checking is disabled, then no host key setup is required. For information about the acfsutil repl init command, refer to acfsutil repl init.

Notes on permissions for ssh-related files

For ssh to work with the keys you have established, you must ensure that permissions are set properly on each node for the relevant .ssh directory and some of the files the directory contains. On each primary node, this refers to the .ssh directory for root. On each standby node, the .ssh directory to check is the one for repluser.

For details on the permissions that should be given to each .ssh directory and key files within the directory, refer to the documentation for your ssh implementation, such as the FILES section of the ssh(1) manual page.

Notes on sshd configuration

After you begin using replication, ssh is started frequently to perform replication operations. On some platforms, the ssh daemon sshd may be configured to log a message through syslog or a similar facility each time an ssh connection is established. To avoid this, the server configuration file /etc/ssh/sshd_config can be modified to specify a lower frequency of logging. The parameter that controls logging is called LogLevel. Connection messages are issued at level INFO. Any lower LogLevel setting, such as ERROR, suppresses those messages. For example, you can suppress log messages by adding the following line to the file:

LogLevel ERROR

Validating your ssh-related key configuration

After you have established the host and user keys for ssh on both your primary and your standby clusters, you can use the command acfsutil repl info -c -u to validate the keys. You run this command as root on each node of each cluster. It takes as arguments all the hostnames or addresses on the remote cluster that the local cluster may use in the future to perform replication.

If you are not using a VIP to connect to your remote cluster, then for a given replication relationship, only one remote hostname or address is provided to acfsutil repl init primary. However, if future relationships involve other remote host addresses, specify the complete set of remote addresses when running the acfsutil repl info -c -u command.

If you are using a VIP to connect to your remote cluster, then you should specify the names or host-specific addresses of all remote hosts on which the VIP may be active. Do not specify the VIP name or an address associated with the VIP. When replication uses ssh to connect to a VIP, the host key returned is the key associated with the host where the VIP is currently active. Only the hostnames or addresses of individual remote nodes are used by ssh in this situation.

The validation command to run on each node of your primary cluster has the following format:

# acfsutil repl info -c -u repluser standby1 [standby2 …] standby-mountpoint

In the command, standbyn specifies the standby cluster hostname or address. The validation command confirms that user repluser can use ssh to connect to each standby hostname or address given, in the same manner as replication initialization. Use the same command format if you are using a VIP, such as standby12_vip, to connect to the cluster. Do not specify the name of the VIP.

If you plan to disable strict host key checking, you can skip this checking by adding the -o sshStrictKey=no option to the command line.

After you have confirmed that each node of your primary cluster can connect to all nodes of your standby cluster, run the validation command again. This time run the command on each node of your standby cluster. Specify a hostname or IP address for all nodes of your primary cluster using the following format:

# acfsutil repl info -c -u repluser primary1 [primary2 ...] primary-mountpoint

In the command, primaryn specifies the primary cluster hostname or address.

Installing ssh and Cygwin on Windows

This section describes how to install Cygwin and start the ssh daemon on Microsoft Windows hosts. This information is only applicable when you want to use Oracle ACFS snapshot-based replication on a Windows host.

Cygwin Requirement for Oracle ACFS Replication

Oracle ACFS snapshot-based replication uses ssh to transfer replication-related data from the primary cluster to the standby cluster. When you use replication on a host running on Microsoft Windows, you must install Cygwin and start the ssh daemon on the host, as described in this section.

Cygwin is essentially a utility that offers a Linux-like environment on a Microsoft Windows host. Technically, it is a DLL (cygwin1.dll) that acts as a Linux API layer providing substantial Linux API functionality. After you install Cygwin, you can configure the ssh daemon on the host. Oracle ACFS replication is certified and supported with Cygwin 2.0.

The ssh daemon enables Oracle ACFS Replication to establish ssh connectivity from the primary cluster running replication to the standby cluster running replication.

Note:

These instructions for installing the ssh daemon result in a daemon that is usable only to log in and run commands as the specific user repluser. The daemon is not intended to work correctly when logging in and running commands as any other user. This restriction results from two factors:

Users defined for Oracle ACFS must be domain-based users.
Enabling the general-purpose use of the ssh daemon for a domain-based user involves creating a domain policy that gives that user some very powerful privileges, including SeTcbPrivilege which lets the user act as part of the Trusted Computing Base. Creating such a policy would not likely be allowed in most corporate environments, so the use of such a policy is not included in these instructions.

Steps Before Installing Cygwin

Before starting with the ssh setup, ensure you are not using OpenSSH and MKSNT by performing the checks in the following steps.

Note that the navigational steps described in this section may vary for different Microsoft Windows operating systems.

Ensure OpenSSH\bin and any directory where mksnt executable files are stored are not in your PATH environment variable. If they are, remove them from the path string by performing the following:
1. Right-click on My Computer and go to Properties.
2. In the System Properties window, click Advanced.
3. In this tab, click Environment Variables.
4. Search for the PATH system variable, select it, and if OpenSSH\bin or mksnt-related values are present in PATH string, click Edit.
5. In the Edit System Variable dialog box, delete these values from PATH string, then click OK.
Stop and disable the ssh daemon if it is running from OpenSSH, MKS or any other source. If the ssh daemon is running, stop and disable it by doing the following:
1. Right-click on My Computer, and select Manage.
2. In the Computer Management window, in the left pane, expand Services and Applications, and select Services.
  - In the right pane, right-click the ssh daemon/MKS Secure Shell service, then click the Stop entry on the menu that appears.
  - In the same pane, right-click the ssh daemon/MKS Secure Shell service, then click the Properties entry on the menu that appears. In the dialog box that opens, select Disabled as the Startup type, and click OK.

Installing Cygwin

To install Cygwin on a Microsoft Windows host, perform the following steps:

Access the following URL, then click Install Cygwin:
```
http://www.cygwin.com/ 
```
Depending on the version of Microsoft Windows you are running, download the 32-bit version or the 64-bit version of the Cygwin setup executable.
Run the setup executable, then click Next to proceed.
On the Choose Installation Type screen, select Install from Internet, then click Next.
On the Choose Installation Directory screen, enter C:\cygwin as the Root Directory, then click Next.
On the Select Local Package Directory screen, select a directory on your local machine where you want to store the downloaded installation files, then click Next.
On the Select Connection Type screen, select appropriate settings to connect to the internet, then click Next.
On the Choose Download Site(s) screen, select any site from the available list, then click Next.
On the select packages screen, ensure that you select the following packages, then click Next. From the Archive category, select unzip and zip. From the Net category, select openssh and openssl. After selecting the packages and clicking Next, the Resolving Dependencies screen is displayed. Click Next to proceed.
On the Installation Status and Create Icons screen, do not make any changes. Click Finish to complete the installation process.

Configuring ssh

This section describes how to configure ssh for Oracle ACFS replication after installing Cygwin on a host.

Choosing Replication Users

Oracle ACFS Replication uses ssh as the transport between the primary and standby clusters, so the user identities under which replication is performed need to be explicitly specified. In the replication process, a privileged user on the primary node uses ssh to log in to the standby node involved in replication. It is not desirable for ssh to log in as a privileged user on the standby node. Instead, a minimally-privileged user identity should be used. The user chosen must be a domain-based user, and must be a member of the ORA_ASMADMIN group.

In this discussion, repladmin and repluser are used to refer to the replication users; however, you would replace repladmin and repladmin with the actual user names that you have selected. The repladmin user refers to the user that runs the acfsutil repl init command on both the primary and the standby. This user must be a member of the Administrators group. The repluser user refers to the user that ssh uses to log in on the standby. This user must be a domain-based user, and must be a member of the ORA_ASMADMIN group, but not a member of the Administrators group. If a suitable user already exists for the use of Oracle RAC, that user should be used as repluser.

For information about user privileges for Oracle ASM, refer to About Privileges for Oracle ASM. For information about running Oracle ACFS acfsutil commands, refer to About Using Oracle ACFS Command-Line Tools.

Configuration Steps

While configuring ssh, you may need to run the cygwin.bat script. While running cygwin.bat on Microsoft Windows Server 2008 and Microsoft Windows Vista, ensure that you invoke the batch file in administrator mode. To do this, right-click the cygwin.bat file and select Run as administrator.

To configure ssh and test your Cygwin setup, follow these steps:

After you install Cygwin, navigate to the C:\cygwin directory, open the Cygwin.bat file in edit mode using any editor, and add the following line before invoking the bash shell.
```
set CYGWIN=binmode ntsec
```
The following lines are the possible contents of the Cygwin.bat file after adding the previous line:
```
@echo off  
C: 
chdir C:\cygwin\bin 
set CYGWIN=binmode ntsec bash --login –i
```
To verify if Cygwin (cygrunsrv) is installed properly, run C:\cygwin\Cygwin.bat, and run the following command:
```
cygrunsrv –h
```
If Cygwin is installed properly, then all Cygwin help options are displayed on the screen. If the command returns an error message, then you may have to reinstall Cygwin.
Define the repladmin and repluser identities at the Windows level.

You can also use existing users instead for these roles. If you define new identities for these roles, note the following:
- The repladmin user must be a member of the Administrators group. It is recommended that repladmin also be a domain-based user. If repladmin is a local user, it should be defined with the same group memberships on all primary nodes.
- The repluser user must be a domain-based user, and must be a member of the ORA_ASMADMIN group.

Configure the sshd service. Run C:\cygwin\Cygwin.bat, and execute the following command:

ssh-host-config

After running the command, you are prompted with the following questions. Appropriate responses are shown in bold. Other output may also appear, but is not shown here.

*** Query: Should StrictModes be used? (yes/no) yes
*** Query: Should privilege separation be used? <yes/no>: yes
*** Query: New local account ’sshd’? <yes/no>: yes
*** Query: Do you want to install sshd as a service?
*** Query: <Say "no" if it is already installed as a service> <yes/no>: yes
*** Query: Enter the value of CYGWIN for the daemon: [] binmode ntsec

Now ssh-host-config outputs some notes concerning the user account required to use passwordless logins. This capability is required by Oracle ACFS replication. The repluser account should be specified as this account.

*** Info: The following privileged accounts were found: 'cyg_server' .
*** Info: This script plans to use 'cyg_server'.
*** Info: 'cyg_server' will only be used by registered services.
*** Query: Do you want to use a different name? (yes/no) yes

You should respond yes to the prompt, and should specify repluser as the name under which you run sshd. You are then prompted with the following questions.

*** Query: Enter the new user name: repluser
*** Query: Reenter: repluser

***Warning: The specified account 'repluser' does not have the
***Warning: required permissions or group memberships.  This may
***Warning: cause problems if not corrected; continuing...
*** Query: Please enter the password for user 'repluser':
*** Query: Reenter:

The above assumes that the user repluser already exists. You may ignore the warning output about missing permissions or group memberships. If the configuration is successful, the following message displays.

Host configuration finished. Have fun!

Ensure that the directory /var/empty exists and is owned by repluser.
Ensure that the repluser and repladmin users are known to Cygwin.

Backup the c:\cygwin\etc\passwd file and then open the file in edit mode. Remove any lines from this file that refer to the repladmin or repluser users. For each user, run the following command. Both users are assumed to be domain-based users.
```
/bin/mkpasswd -d -u repladmin >> /etc/passwd
```
Ensure that the home directory named for each user in /etc/passwd exists. If necessary, create it. For example, if /home/repladmin is the directory shown for user repladmin, perform the following to create the necessary directory.
```
mkdir -p /home/repladmin
chown repladmin /home/repladmin
```
Ensure that the ssh daemon starts, and is configured to start automatically:
1. Right-click on My Computer, and select Manage.
2. In the Computer Management window, in the left pane, expand Services and Applications, and select Services.
3. In the right pane, right-click the CYGWIN sshd service, then click the Properties entry on the menu that appears. In the dialog box that opens, select Automatic as the Startup type, and click OK.

If the ssh daemon does not start, view the c:\cygwin\var\log\sshd.log file for information that relates to the failure of the startup process.

Getting the public key for repladmin from the primary

A public key for repladmin defined on each node of your primary cluster must be known to repluser on each node of your standby cluster.

repluser@standby $ ls -ld ~/.ssh
drwx------+ 1 repluser Domain Users 4096 2016-02-23 11:27 .ssh

If a public key for repladmin is defined on a given primary node, then it resides in a .pub file, such as ~repladmin/.ssh/id_rsa.pub. If a public key file exists, then add its contents to the set of keys authorized to log in as repluser on each node of the standby where replication is run. Append the key to the file ~repluser/.ssh/authorized_keys2 on each standby node, creating this file if necessary.

If a public key file does not exist, generate a public and private key pair on the primary by running the following command as repladmin.

# ssh-keygen -t rsa

You can press the enter key in response to each prompt issued by the command. Copy the resulting .pub file to each standby node.

You have the option to share the same public/private key pair for repladmin across all of the nodes in your primary cluster, or to establish a different key pair for each primary node. If the same public key is valid for repladmin across all nodes in your primary cluster, then only that key must be added to the file ~repluser/.ssh/authorized_keys2 on each node of your standby cluster. If each primary node has its own public key for repladmin, then all the public keys must be added to the file. In either case, you can minimize work by copying the updated authorized_keys2 file on a given node of the standby to the other nodes of the cluster.

Getting the standby host key

A host key for each standby node where replication may run must be known on each primary node where replication may run. One way to generate the correct key is to run ssh manually as the repladmin user from each primary node to each standby node. If the correct host key is not known already, then a warning displays and you can enable ssh to add the key.

Note that there are two users involved in the ssh connection. While ssh on the primary node connects to the standby node as repladmin, ssh logs in on the standby node as repluser. Any command run by ssh on the standby runs with the privileges of repluser, not with repladmin privileges.

Because the primary node connects to the standby node as user repladmin, the host key for the standby node must be added to the known_hosts file of the repladmin user, not the file for repluser. The following is an example of obtaining a host key:

[repladmin@primary usm]# ssh repluser@standby date
The authenticity of host 'standby (10.137.13.85)' can't be established.
RSA key fingerprint is 1b:a9:c6:68:47:b4:ec:7c:df:3a:f0:2a:6f:cf:a7:0a.
Are you sure you want to continue connecting (yes/no)?

If you respond with yes, then the ssh setup is complete. A host key for host standby is stored in the known_hosts file (~repladmin/.ssh/known_hosts) on the host primary for the user repladmin.

standby1,10.242.20.22 ssh-rsa
AAAAB3NzaC1yc2EAAAADAQABAAABAQC3pM2YTd4UUiEWEoCKDGgaTgsmPkQToDrdtU+JtVIq/96muivU
BaJUK83aqzeNIQkh+hUULsUdgKoKT5bxrWYqhY6AlTEqNgBHjBrJt9C73BbQd9y48jsc2G+WQWyuI/
+s1Q+hIJdBNMxvMBQAfisPWWUcaIx9Y/JzlPgF6lRP2cbfqAzixDot9fqRrAKL3G6A75A/6TbwmEW07d1zqOv
l7ZGyeDYf5zQ72F/V0P9UgMEt/5DmcYTn3kTVGjOTbnRBe4A4lY4rVw5c+nZBDFre66XtORfQgwQB5ztW/Pi
08GYbcIszKoZx2HST9AZxYIAgcrnNYG2Ae0K6QLxxxScP
standby2,10.242.20.23 ssh-rsa
AAAAB3NzaC1yc2EAAAADAQABAAABAQDIszcjzNtKN03SY8Kl846skFTVP1HF/ykswbmkctEjL6KTWTW+NR
U4MGbvkBqqdXxuPCR7aoGO2U3PEOg1UVf3DWUoux8IRvqKU+dJcdTibMFkDAIhTnzb14gZ/lRTjn+GYsuP5
Qz2vgL/U0ki887mZCRjWVL1b5FNH8sXBUV2QcD7bjF98VXF6n4gd5UiIC3jv6l2nVTKDwtNHpUTS1dQAi+1D
tr0AieZTsuxXMaDdUZHgKDotjciMB3mCkKm/u3IFoioDqdZE4+vITX9G7DBN4CVPXawp+b5Kg8X9P+08Eehu
tMlBJ5lafy1bxoVlXUDLVIIFBJNKrsqBvxxxpS7

To enable the use of the VIP, you would modify these two lines to read as follows:

standby12_vip,standby1,10.242.20.22 ssh-rsa
AAAAB3NzaC1yc2EAAAADAQABAAABAQC3pM2YTd4UUiEWEoCKDGgaTgsmPkQToDrdtU+JtVIq/96muivU
BaJUK83aqzeNIQkh+hUULsUdgKoKT5bxrWYqhY6AlTEqNgBHjBrJt9C73BbQd9y48jsc2G+WQWyuI/
+s1Q+hIJdBNMxvMBQAfisPWWUcaIx9Y/JzlPgF6lRP2cbfqAzixDot9fqRrAKL3G6A75A/6TbwmEW07d1zqOv
l7ZGyeDYf5zQ72F/V0P9UgMEt/5DmcYTn3kTVGjOTbnRBe4A4lY4rVw5c+nZBDFre66XtORfQgwQB5ztW/Pi
08GYbcIszKoZx2HST9AZxYIAgcrnNYG2Ae0K6QLxxxScP
standby12_vip,standby2,10.242.20.23 ssh-rsa
AAAAB3NzaC1yc2EAAAADAQABAAABAQDIszcjzNtKN03SY8Kl846skFTVP1HF/ykswbmkctEjL6KTWTW+NR
U4MGbvkBqqdXxuPCR7aoGO2U3PEOg1UVf3DWUoux8IRvqKU+dJcdTibMFkDAIhTnzb14gZ/lRTjn+GYsuP5
Qz2vgL/U0ki887mZCRjWVL1b5FNH8sXBUV2QcD7bjF98VXF6n4gd5UiIC3jv6l2nVTKDwtNHpUTS1dQAi+1D
tr0AieZTsuxXMaDdUZHgKDotjciMB3mCkKm/u3IFoioDqdZE4+vITX9G7DBN4CVPXawp+b5Kg8X9P+08Eehu
tMlBJ5lafy1bxoVlXUDLVIIFBJNKrsqBvxxxpS7

Note:

By default, replication enables strict host key checking by ssh, to ensure that the primary node connects to the intended standby node or cluster when it runs ssh. However, if you are certain that this checking is unneeded, such as the case when the primary and standby clusters communicate over a private network, the use of strict host key checking by ssh can be disabled. For information about disabling strict host key checking, refer to the /o sshStrictKey=no option of the acfsutil repl init primary command. If strict host key checking is disabled, then no host key setup is required. For information about the acfsutil repl init command, refer to acfsutil repl init.

Adding keys for the SYSTEM user

Oracle ACFS replication uses a daemon running on a node of the primary cluster to control the progress of replication. This daemon is automatically started using the identity NT_AUTHORITY\SYSTEM. With this daemon, replication, using ssh, is able to transfer and apply primary data to the standby site.

The processes started by the daemon have the identity of the daemon. If the user is NT_AUTHORITY\SYSTEM, that is the user actually contacting the standby through ssh. ssh searches in the home directory for the SYSTEM user for a public key to present to the standby, and checks there to verify the host key presented by the standby.

To enable the daemon's successful use of ssh, the contents of the .ssh directory set up for repladmin on the primary should be copied to a .ssh directory in the home directory for SYSTEM. Use a location for this directory that is parallel to the locations used for other home directories.

For instance, if the home directory for user repladmin is /home/repladmin, then use /home/SYSTEM as the home directory for SYSTEM. Create the .ssh directory like this, while logged in as repladmin.

First, create the home directory for SYSTEM if it does not already exist:

$ mkdir /home/SYSTEM

Next, copy the .ssh directory for repladmin into the directory for SYSTEM:

 $ cd  $HOME
 $ cp -p -R .ssh /home/SYSTEM

Testing Your Cygwin Setup

Now test your Cygwin setup. Using a different computer that has the ssh client available, execute the following command as the user repladmin:

ssh -l repluser host-address date

where host-address refers to the host where you just configured ssh. For example:

ssh -l repluser standby1.us.example.com date

If you have completed the installation and configuring steps successfully, the previous command should run without prompting for a password.

If you experience a process fork failure, memory leak error, or a file access error after configuring ssh, view the following link for a workaround:

http://cygwin.com/faq.html

If you are unable to find a workaround for your problem, report your problem to the Cygwin community using the following link:

http://cygwin.com/problems.html

Upgrading to Oracle ACFS Snapshot-Based Replication

This section describes the upgrade to Oracle ACFS snapshot-based replication. With Oracle Grid Infrastructure 12c release 2 (12.2), Oracle ACFS snapshot-based replication becomes the supported Oracle ACFS replication implementation. If you have a replication environment from a release before 12.2, then you must upgrade your existing replication installation to snapshot-based replication when you upgrade to Oracle Grid Infrastructure 12c release 2 (12.2).

Note:

After the replication upgrade process has started, it must be completed. The process cannot be rolled back.
Oracle Flex ASM should be enabled, and if necessary a password file conversion performed, before upgrading to snapshot-based replication.

Oracle Flex ASM must be enabled for any existing instance when the instance is upgraded to Oracle Grid Infrastructure 12c release 2 (12.2). If a password file exists in the instance to support replication, the file must be enabled for use in the new Oracle Flex ASM instance. For example, if an instance had a previous ORACLE_SID set to ASM and a current ORACLE_SID set to APX1, then the following steps must be performed:

Copy the existing orapw+ASM file to an +APX1 version

$ cp /oraroot/app/12.2.0/has0626/dbs/orapw+ASM /oraroot/app/12.2.0/has0626/dbs/orapw+APX1

Create a new text file called init+APX1.ora in the dbs directory and add only the following line to the new file:
```
remote_login_passwordfile = exclusive 
```
Restart the Oracle ASM proxy (APX) instance.
```
$ asmcmd shutdown --target APX --immediate
```
Ensure that the environment variable ORACLE_SID is set to the Oracle ASM proxy (APX) instance. Then restart the instance.
```
$ asmcmd startup --pfile init+APX1.ora
```

Snapshot-based replication uses ssh as the transport between the primary and standby clusters. Before starting the upgrade process, you must configure ssh as described in Configuring ssh for Use With Oracle ACFS Replication.

Before upgrading to snapshot-based replication, you must upgrade your standby cluster system to Oracle Grid Infrastructure 12c release 2 (12.2).This cluster upgrade should be completed within 24 hours. The standby cluster continues to run existing replication during this upgrade process. Next, upgrade to Oracle Grid Infrastructure 12c release 2 (12.2) on the primary cluster. This upgrade should also be completed within 24 hours. During this upgrade, the primary cluster continues to run existing replication that was installed before 12.2. After the completion of the Oracle Grid Infrastructure 12c release 2 (12.2) upgrade of the standby and primary clusters, the existing replication implementation installed before 12.2 is not supported.

Immediately following the upgrade of the two clusters, you must set the COMPATIBLE.ADVM disk group attribute associated with the file systems to be involved in replication to 12.2.0.0.0. Now you are ready to transition to snapshot-based replication. The transition can made with one of the following options:

Terminate your existing replication and initialize to use snapshot-based replication. This option is recommended if the amount of data being replicated is small (less than a few hundred gigabytes). This option may also be preferable if your primary file system cannot easily be restricted to being mounted on only one node, or if activity on the primary cannot easily be quiesced.
Run the acfsutil repl upgrade command to upgrade your existing replication environment without terminating and initializing replication. This option avoids the need to transfer the entire contents of your primary file system to the standby by enabling snapshot-based replication to continue from the point where existing replication has stopped. This option is advantageous when larger amounts of data are being replicated. Because very little data is transferred by the upgrade process, you can expect the process to complete quickly.

The following list provides details on running the acfsutil repl upgrade command options to upgrade to snapshot-based replication.

Before starting the replication upgrade process, you must ensure that your primary file system is mounted on only one node of the primary cluster. In addition, it is strongly recommended that you quiesce all application updates to the primary file system, then run acfsutil repl sync apply one final time to ensure all changes on the primary are replicated.
The initial step in the upgrade process is to run the acfsutil repl upgrade prepare command on the primary cluster. This command specifies the user and host or interface name that will be used for snapshot-based replication, as well as the primary mount point. The user and host names are given with the -s option, exactly as they are for the acfsutil repl init primary command used for snapshot-based replication.
The next step in the process is to upgrade replication on the standby cluster, by running the acfsutil repl upgrade standby command. This command specifies the user to be used for snapshot-based replication, as well as the standby mount point. The user name is given with the -u option, exactly as it is for the acfsutil repl init standby command used for snapshot-based replication.
The final step in the process is to run the aacfsutil repl upgrade primary command on the primary cluster. This is the command that automatically terminates the previous replication deployment and initiates snapshot-based replication. This command accepts any of the command-line options accepted by the acfsutil repl init primary command for snapshot-based replication, except for the -m and -s options, as that information is obtained from the now-terminated previous replication environment.
After the acfsutil repl upgrade primary command completes, snapshot-based replication should be active between the affected primary and standby clusters, exactly as though the acfsutil repl init commands had been run with snapshot-based replication in the 12.2 release. You can use the command acfsutil repl info -c on both the primary and standby cluster to confirm the status of replication on each cluster.

Note:

If an error occurs in running either acfsutil repl upgrade standby or acfsutil repl upgrade primary, then consider the following:

Depending on the error, replication may appear to be uninitialized (acfsutil repl info may indicate that) until the upgrade command has completed successfully.
To continue with the upgrade, you should correct whatever error was indicated by the failing upgrade command, then simply re-issue the failing command. The command may be re-issued multiple times.